Jeffery Turnbull has been acquitted of charges of sexual assault against a fellow Hamilton police officer in 2022 after a trial that commenced in January. Ontario Justice Jennifer Marie Campitelli delivered the verdict in Burlington, expressing doubts about the credibility of the complainant while siding with Turnbull.
During the trial, Crown lawyer Jason Nicol alleged that Turnbull had engaged in inappropriate behavior towards the younger officer, including sending unsolicited messages, gifts, and making unwanted advances that culminated in the alleged assault. The complainant testified that Turnbull persistently contacted her, gave her gifts, and coerced her into visiting his home where the assault occurred.
The defense countered by claiming that the relationship was consensual, presenting text messages as evidence of a friendly dynamic between the two. Turnbull maintained that the encounter was consensual and planned, while the defense lawyer argued that the Crown failed to prove non-consent beyond a reasonable doubt.
Justice Campitelli reviewed the evidence presented by both sides, finding Turnbull’s account more plausible and consistent with independent evidence. She criticized the complainant for inconsistencies in her testimony, including discrepancies in dates and receiving gifts from Turnbull. Ultimately, Campitelli concluded that the Crown had not proven lack of consent, leading to Turnbull’s acquittal.
Turnbull, who remains suspended with pay, had union representatives supporting him throughout the trial. The Hamilton Police Association acknowledged the challenges faced by both parties and pledged support for their next steps. The case may undergo further investigation by the Hamilton Police Service’s Professional Standards team or external oversight agencies.
The complainant, still an active police constable, and Turnbull could potentially resume their duties pending internal procedures. The legal process was described as arduous and demanding for all involved over the past 3½ years, according to union officials.
In case of immediate danger or mental health concerns, individuals are urged to contact emergency services or seek support from crisis helplines and local services. Additionally, resources for mental health assistance are available through various organizations for those in need.